Arxis Financial Logo

Certified Public Accountants
(805) 306-7890

Litigation Consulting


Forensic Accounting - Fraud - Business Valuation

October 2012

Recent Case:

“Dissenting Shareholders in a Buyout – Litigation Consulting and Business Valuation Issues”

Summary of issue:
Recently, Arxis Financial was contacted to assist with the initial strategy discussion regarding a developing shareholder dispute. At issue was how to negotiate the departure of three partners without going through the process of expensive litigation.

The situation was that the majority of partners wanted the three partners to go. The three partners under the shareholder agreement had enough votes to block any formal move to force them out. Further, the written agreement clearly stated that the buy-in amount for each partner was $100 and the buy-out for each partner was $100. State law where the firm was located clearly stated that clients and cases were owned by partner- lawyers and not the firm. So, in addition to the $100, the departing partners could also take their clients with them.

Further inquiry revealed that the balance sheet of the firm was substantial, as it included minimal cash and substantial accounts receivable and work-in-process. The shareholder agreement established a formula for compensation of the partners that basically shared revenue equally, regardless of the partner's contribution. A review of the history of the firm revealed that the shareholder agreement had been followed exactly for decades. Every incoming partner had paid $100 and every departing partner had received $100 and their clients. Compensation for decades had followed the formula.

So what was the issue here? The remaining partners all agreed that the three departing partners needed to go. However, under the shareholder agreement the three departing partners had enough votes to effectively prevent the forced departure. Stalemate!

Arxis work:
Arxis Financial was contacted to discuss one question: What is the likely position of both sides if this case goes to court?

Our conclusion was that the remaining partners will hold the line at the shareholders agreement: $100 and their clients. The departing partners would likely pay for a valuation of the entire firm and claim that if the firm was sold, they were due the sale price times their ownership percentage. It seemed to us that the low end was $100 and the high end of the negotiating range was their portion of the value of the firm.

It turned out that was exactly the position of both sides in this dispute. Given the potential for expensive litigation with devastating results to both sides (e.g., forced dissolution under the laws of the state where the firm was located), cooler heads prevailed and a settlement was reached.



Upcoming Speaking Engagements for Chris Hamiltion

"Business Valuation Fundamentals, Techniques, and Theory" in San Diego, CA
"Cost of Capital" in San Diego, CA
"Forensic Accounting & Fraud" - CalCPA, Beverly Hills, CA
"Advanced Business Valuation" in Atlanta, GA
"Valuation: Income and Asset Approaches" in Atlanta GA
"Cost of Capital" in Chicago, IL


Practice Profile:

Litigation Consulting Services for Partnership Disputes & Dissolutions

Arxis Financial's "Litigation Consulting" practice provides objective and independent evaluation of the economic and financial issues involved in partnership disputes and dissolutions. Our involvement may include assistance with technical and complex discovery issues; interpretation of the partnership agreement's tax and accounting provisions; case strategy; projections of proposed dissolutions under several different scenarios; and valuation of entities, control interests, and non-control partnership interests. A significant strength of our practice is that accounting and valuation expertise can be hired in one expert, which saves the client fees and increases the efficiency of the case. Clients are pleased with Arxis Financial's abilities to clearly, persuasively, and accurately present arguments in simple understandable terms, regardless of the complexity of the matter.


Partner Profile:

The Litigation Consulting practice is headed by partner Chris L. Hamilton, CPA, CFE, CVA, DABFA. Mr. Hamilton is a Certified Public Accountant, Certified Fraud Examiner, Certified Valuation Analyst, and a Diplomate with the American Board of Forensic Accounting. He is a licensed life and disability insurance agent and a General Securities Representative. Mr. Hamilton has published articles in several publications, and has made presentations at national conferences, training institutes and seminars on topics including forensic accounting, fraud and business appraisal.


Arxis Financial respects your time and your privacy. If you no longer want to receive e-mails such as this one, please click here.
Note: Please do not respond to this E-Mail. The reply to E-Mail address is not a monitored account.

Copyright 2012 Arxis Financial. Articles may not be reprinted without permission.

Chris Hamilton Photo

Chris Hamilton, CPA CFE, CVA, DABFA
(805) 306-7890
@ArxisChris on Twitter

Arxis Financial Logo

Litigation Consulting

Forensic Accounting - Fraud - Business Valuation


Clients know us for results. Opposing counsel know Arxis for wishing they had hired us.